Congress to Take Up Net's Future
New York Times (01/10/07) P. C1; Labaton, Stephen
The debate over Net neutrality continues, as new legislation is being
drafted by Congress and familiar arguments from each side are being voiced.
Sen. Byron L. Dorgan (D-S.D.) and Sen. Olympia J. Snow (R-Maine)
introduced a bill last week that would prevent Internet service providers
from charging content providers for preferred access over their network.
"The success of the Internet has been its openness and the ability of
anyone anywhere in this country to go on the Internet and reach the world,"
Sen. Dorgan said. Rep. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) has also announced plans to
introduce similar legislation. Content providers and the consumer groups
that support them claim that New neutrality laws are needed to ensure the
ability to develop and make new and improved services available to users,
and to help ensure the survival of small businesses. However, telephone
and cable companies claim that such laws would prevent them from making
investments in expanded networks that would benefit the general economy.
While the issue is normally thought to be split along partisan lines, a
June 2006 vote in the House saw 58 Democrats vote against a Net neutrality
measure put forth by Rep. Markey. Many Democrats who oppose the
legislation are allied with unions, who believe that allowing service
providers to charge for priority access, or simply for access in general,
will lead to further construction of network infrastructure, meaning demand
will increase for the services offered by members of these unions.
Nevertheless, new Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) is a big
supporter of Net Neutrality legislation, and the recent FCC ruling on the
AT&T acquisition of SBC, which states that AT&T cannot offer a service that
"privileges, degrades or prioritizes any packet" for a period of two years,
also adds some momentum to the previously stagnated drive for Net
neutrality.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
ACM Names 41 Fellows for Contributing to Computing and
IT
AScribe Newswire (01/08/07)
ACM has named 41 members ACM Fellows for their work in both the practical
and theoretical aspects of computing and IT. "The breadth and depth of the
contributions these computing scientists and professionals have made to our
world and the way we live are remarkable," said ACM President Stuart
Feldman. "These individuals deserve our acclaim for providing dedicated
leadership, solving complex problems, and pursuing productive careers in
information technology." From the corporate sector: Fellows named from
Microsoft Research were commended for a range of efforts, including
information retrieval, human-computer interaction, computer architecture,
and computer graphics; Google Fellows for their data integration, AI,
information retrieval, and knowledge representation work; IBM Fellows for
their database systems and scalable distributed systems contributions; and
Yahoo, Intel, and HP Labs Fellows for their work in fields including
knowledge discovery and data mining, parallel computing, and sensor
networks, among others. Of Universities with ACM Fellows, MIT Fellows were
recognized for their contributions to dataflow computing and verification,
algebraic specification and abstract data types, and parallel and
distributed computing; Stanford Fellows for work in network switching and
queuing and multiprocessor design. Other Universities with Fellows include
Rutgers; Purdue; Northeastern; Northwestern; Penn State; Penn; Michigan at
Ann Arbor; Texas at Austin; Maryland; Brigham Young; Rochester; UC San
Diego; UC Los Angeles; Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; Colorado at Boulder;
Portland State; and Brown. Worldwide, one Fellow from the Class of 2006
was named at each of the following: National Taiwan University in Taipei,
the Ecole Polytechnique Federale, Lausanne, in Switzerland, and the
University of Dundee in Scotland. For non-profit research institutes:
Argonne National Laboratories, RAND Corporation, and the International
Computer Science Institutes all had ACM Fellows, who worked in fields
ranging from message passing protocols to Internet measurement and
intrustion detection. A full list of the 2006 ACM Fellow can be found at
www.acm.org/awards.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Scott Rosenberg: What Makes Software So Hard
CIO Insight (01/05/07) Cone, Edward
In his book, "Dreaming In Code," Salon founding editor Scott Rosenberg
examines the persistence of a dysfunctional software development culture,
using the trials and travails of the Open Source Applications Foundation's
initiative to build Chandler, an improved personal information manager, as
an example. Rosenberg says missed deadlines, postponements, and other
problems are par for the course in the development of nearly all software
systems, and unlike classic engineering, there is little analysis of past
mistakes. He agrees with the 1975 text by Frederick Brooks, "The Mythical
Man-Month," that throwing more programmers at a software project can become
a hindrance. Rosenberg believes the difficulty of software development
lies in the clash between industry's philosophy of pushing for exponential
development and the linear pace of human experience and creativity. "One
reason the whole engineering approach has proven so difficult for the
software field is also one of the unique things about software: Once a
particular problem is solved, it's almost infinitely cheaper to use the
existing solution," the author observes. Rosenberg dismisses the idea that
a "physics of software" is likely or possible, but says developers are
loath to accept this fact. According to him, a combination of cultural and
managerial difficulties contribute to many problems in major projects.
Rosenberg thinks it makes more sense for developers to follow an iterative
release-test-improve strategy through techniques such as agile programming
instead of attempting to make a huge, all-or-nothing leap toward the
project's ultimate goal.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Congress Off to Slow Start With Tech
CNet (01/09/07) Broache, Anne
The newly elected Democratic Congress does not have plans for introducing
technology legislation in its initial 100-hours agenda, but Democratic
aides say such issues are important to the economy and will be addressed in
time. Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said the "innovation
agenda" is very important to her, including providing nationwide broadband
Internet within five years and boosting grants for science and math
scholarships. Although such hot-button issues as patent reform, H-1B
visas, and Net neutrality are temporarily off the table, some
technology-related issues are being addressed right away. A bill is being
introduced by Democrats that would increase oversight of the government
warrantless wiretapping program, in part by adding to the investigatory
power of the Department of Homeland Security's chief privacy officer, in
order to monitor expected data-intensive watch lists and identification
regimes; another measure will concentrate on the privacy implications of
government data mining. Senator Ted Stevens (R-Alaska) is receiving
Justice Department support for his bill that would require jail time for
commercial Web site owners who did not label relevant sites as sexually
explicit. The NSA Oversight Act, which has been introduced by a Republican
and a Democrat, would reform the process for granting warrants for
wiretaps. A permanent ban on Internet taxes was proposed by a bipartisan
group at the Senate's first session, but another proposal made by Stevens
would make communications services subsidize service in rural areas,
schools and libraries; the fees currently come from the long-distance
revenues of telecoms. Finally, a measure was introduced by Rep.
Christopher Smith (R-N.J.) that would prohibit American companies from
blocking U.S. government content on the Internet in foreign countries, or
provide foreign governments with information about users.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
CMU Professor Investigates Vote
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review (01/09/07) Amen, Rob
The design of Florida's electronic ballot may have led 18,000 people to
not vote for a candidate in the 13th Congressional District during last
fall's general election, although seven leading computer scientists
continue to study the software used in the touch-screen voting machines. A
study from Michael Herron, an associate professor in the Department of
Government at Dartmouth College, cites poor ballot design as the likely
problem. The 25-page e-ballot had the race between Republican Vern
Buchanan and Democrat Christine Jennings atop the second page, and it was
in between two races that had a large number of candidates. Some voters
may not have realized the Buchanan-Jennings race was a separate contest,
says Carnegie Mellon University computer scientist Mike Shamos, who added
that "the banner for the [U.S. House of Representatives] race was very
subdued." After testing the software of the iVotronic machines of Election
Systems & Software, the Florida Department of State uncovered no flaws and
believes ballot design and voter intent were behind the lack of votes.
Like the state, the research team has not found any problems with the
software so far. "[The work] is not complete, and we might yet find
something," says Shamos, who expects the team to report its findings in
January.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
After Years of Effort, Voice Recognition Is Starting to
Work
Wall Street Journal (01/10/07) P. B1; Gomes, Lee
While fully functional, ubiquitous voice recognition remains far away, new
technology is allowing more and more machines to understand spoken
commands. At this year's Consumer Electronics Show, Bill Gates and Ford
Motor executives discussed the use of Microsoft Sync software to allow
drivers to adjust their car stereo or make phone calls using voice
commands. Microsoft Vista has speech recognition software included in it,
but Microsoft is not currently promoting or providing much support for its
use. Naturally Speaking is the present leader for PC speech recognition,
as most who use it agree that it works rather well out of the box and that
corrections are easily made. This software allows a user wearing a
headphone to dictate text that then appears on the screen; the software
improves in effectiveness as it trains itself to a user's unique speaking
style. Analyst Bill Meisel says the technology is mostly applied to legal
and medical practices, as the average PC user is perfectly happy using a
mouse and keyboard to communicate with their computer. Increasing computer
power means that voice recognition programs, which use statistical methods
to match spoken sounds to words in a database, can now be trained for
thousands of hours before being shipped, compared with dozens of hours 10
years ago. Meisel predicts that speech recognition will next appear in
search engines, as both Yahoo and Google are planning to release
voice-enabled search for mobile devices. IBM has envisioned software that
can create transcripts from meetings of as many as four or five people, as
well as translation software for broadcasts. The latter technology is far
from being perfected, but it is currently able to convey general
meaning.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Apple Packs All Kinds of High-Tech Goodies Into
iPhone
USA Today (01/10/07) P. 4B; Baig, Edward C.
The long-awaited Apple iPhone was unveiled by Steve Jobs at Macworld in
San Francisco on Tuesday, and its capabilities seem to mark a new direction
in cell phone technology. The device features a 3.5 inch touch-screen
display that can detect whether it is being held horizontally or vertically
and orient itself accordingly; another sensor detects when the device is
being lifted to a user's ear so the display can be turned off, saving power
and preventing any buttons from being inadvertently touched. While music
cannot be wirelessly downloaded from iTunes, the iPhone can be docked and
connected to a computer in the same way as any iPod. A feature known as
Cover Flow lets users scroll through album covers to find the music they
want; podcasts, TV shows, and movies can all be viewed on the device as
well. Phone numbers and other contact information from a PC or Mac can be
transferred to the device. Voicemail is displayed visually, allowing users
to choose those messages that interest them and ignore those that do not.
A full-scale version of Apple's Safari Web browser is included on the
device, and several free email options are available. The interface also
includes Widgets, the light applications that are found on Macs, which
provide real-time information such as weather or stock prices. The phone
works on Cingular's GSM and Edge wireless networks, and offers both
Bluetooth and Wi-Fi support. Battery life is limited to five hours when
talking and browsing the Web.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Spafford Leads as Computer Advisor, Scholar
Purdue Exponent (01/10/07) Thomas, Andrea
Eugene Spafford is internationally known for his work in information
security and ethics, but has always been respected for his dedication and
positive attitude toward his field, his ability to work with people, and
his sense of humor. Despite once quipping that trying to get useful
information from the Internet is like trying to take a sip from a fire
hose, he has not abandoned his own efforts to improve Internet
functionality. "I'm intrigued by the problem," says the ACM U.S. Public
Policy Committee Chairman and Purdue University professor of computer
science and electrical and computer engineering. "I think there is an
incredible potential there; it's an interesting challenge." He still runs
the Center for Education and Research in Information Assurance and
Security, which was the first of its kind when he developed it. Spafford
works a great deal at bringing talented individuals into computing, but
devotes an equal amount of energy to making sure that those already in
computing are paying attention to more than just the computers. He says,
"It's important to think about people and communication. There are issues
that don't get solved with programs or mathematics; the field is beginning
to change to recognize that, but it's got a ways to go." Over his career,
Spafford claims to have learned three valuable lessons: That "Individuals
can make a difference;" that trying new things is very beneficial, as "Some
people seem very daring and some people seem very lucky, but you can make a
lot of luck by actually thinking a little bit and then trying things;" and
that promoting students and colleagues is the most rewarding thing he does,
even though this is not a commonly held idea "in business or personal
relationships." For more information on USACM, visit
http://www.acm.org/usacm
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Finding Patterns of Importance in a Deluge of Data
Dartmouth News (01/09/07)
Two Dartmouth engineers have devised PQS, an algorithmic and software
framework they say is an ideal means of drawing conclusions from the
massive amounts of data gathered by computer network monitors, surveillance
cameras, financial records, and countless other sources. PQS researcher
and Dartmouth engineering professor George Cybenko says, "PQS closes the
gap between gathering a tremendous amount of valuable data and figuring out
what the data means." The system can be used to analyze credit reports in
order to detect identity theft, find attacks on computer networks, and
track activity at national borders, among other tasks. Cybenko adds, "PQS
can do for discrete, categorical data analysis problems what classical
times series analysis did for finance and control systems where the data
are numerical." The two engineers founded their work upon the idea that
sensed environments of any kind are made of processes with unique elements;
PQS is able to observe and comprehend the changes that occur in these
processes. Cybenko's partner on the PQS project, Dartmouth Thayer School
research associate and lecturer Vincent Berk, says he finds the network
security monitoring capabilities of PQS the most exciting. He says, "PQS
brings together the information, and effectively focuses on the most
important issues first. To my knowledge there has not been a new software
technology that is this versatile since the introduction of relational
databases."
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Technology Clears a Path for Putting Robots to
Work
Boston Globe (01/08/07) Bray, Hiawatha; Joh, Carolyn Y.
New products are bringing the consumer robotics market into the realm of
functional, customizable household tools, and allow them to do much more
than simply entertain. This year's CES is hosting two new robotics
toolkits: One from iRobot, the Roomba creator, and the other from
Microsoft. IRobot Chairman Helen Greiner says, "There's a lot of people
with a passion to build robots. We let you basically hit the ground
running--literally running." The $129 iRobot Create is basically the
foundation of the Roomba, minus the vacuum capabilities, and can have
customized parts and software added to it. Robots have become less
expensive thanks to falling costs of sensors, memory, and other technology,
but the new platforms being released are expected to have a bigger impact
on robotics than lower prices will. Microsoft Robotics Group general
manager Tandy Trower says that those in the field are "all saying something
significant is beginning to come together here, but it's being limited;
it's being held back because it's just too hard for people to invest and
get started in this technology." With platforms that take away the trouble
of writing software for robots, this democratization of robotics is
expected to signify the next step in computing: "When the PC will get up
off the desktop," as Bill Gates says. Robotics Trends President Dan Kara
says that "devices that bridge the gap between the virtual world of
computers and the real world of mechanical objects" are the "next big
thing" that the industry has been searching for.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Whoosh! Goes the Internet: International Research Team
Blazes the Optical Trail with Record-Setting Molecules
Washington State University (01/02/07)
New organic molecules that convert light energy into usable form with
unprecedented efficiency could allow for incredibly fast optical
technology. The molecules, known as chromophores, recently exhibited the
level of "optical brawn" theorized in 1999 by WSU physicist Mark Kuzyk, who
led this most recent research, and are 50 percent more effective than any
molecules previously tested. University of Leuven chemist Koen Clays had
begun using a tested known as hyper-Rayleigh scattering, which measures the
strength of a molecule's interaction with light, when he realized that some
of the molecules he had been sent to test were the type that Kuzyk
mentioned in his 1999 paper. Head author of the paper detailing the WSU
findings and WSU and University of Leuven joint Ph.D. student in chemistry
Xavier Perez-Moreno says, "We use the quantum limits to try to get a
clearer view of the nonlinear optical interaction and we wish to unveil the
unifying principles behind the interaction of light and matter--a very
ambitious goal." Lehigh University physicist Ivan Biaggio says the
combined work "is a very important contribution that may help the community
to finally deliver the all-optical switching performances that are needed
for tomorrow�s all-optical data-processing networks, an aim that has eluded
researchers for 20 years." The new design that has emerged includes one
electron-donating component at one end of every molecule and an
electron-receiving component at the other end; while previous efforts tried
to smooth out the "bridge" that connects the end of the molecules, Kuzyk
found that making this structure "bumpy" actually improves the electron's
interaction with light, because as he explains, "By inserting these speed
bumps, you're causing it to bunch up in certain places, and preventing it
from interfering with itself."
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Major Blend of Aesthetic, Technical Skills
Daily Northwestern (01/09/07) French, Julie
A new Northwestern University School of Communications adjunct major,
called Animate Arts, combines disciplines that would not normally be
grouped together, including computer science, art, and music, in order to
allow students to experience and gain an understanding of work in fields
very different from their own. The faculty and students stress that
neither art, music, or computer skills are required for students to enroll
in the major. Four core Animate Arts courses give students a fundamental
basis in these disciplines, and additional electives and a senior project
let them pursue their own interests. The program has attracted students
from majors such as theatre, economics, and engineering. Since most
Animate Arts students are skilled in a single discipline, the program
allows them to diversify their skills and fill in knowledge gaps in order
to provide them with a comprehensive educational experience. Ian Horswill,
program director and associate professor in the electrical engineering and
computer science department, says many students expect the program to be a
video game design major, but he stresses the program is not vocational
training. However, video games design does require several different
skills, so the Animate Arts' "theory-centered" approach could be very
beneficial to someone interested in this field; some students have modified
video games for their projects.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Researchers: Hack Will Help Kill HD DVD Copy
Protection
IDG News Service (01/08/07) McMillan, Robert
A hacker has recently published software, known as BackupHDDVD, that could
facilitate the cracking of the Advanced Access Content System (AACS) copy
protection encryption used on HD DVD and Blu-Ray disks. The software
itself did not crack the encryption, but if the right title keys, numeric
codes used to unlock digital content, are found, BackupHDDVD could allow
users to unscramble the content of a disk. Princeton computer science
student Alex Halderman and researcher Ed Felten say the software is "the
first step in the meltdown of AACS." Content Scrambling Software (CSS),
the system used to protect DVD, was hacked by three individuals only a few
years after it release. While AACS allows Hollywood to revoke a key,
meaning changing a new movie so its keys cannot be read by a HD DVD or
Blu-Ray player that has been cracked, this system only works if hackers
publish their findings, and even if a key is revoked, disks that have
already been published cannot be changed. Halderman says, "What the future
looks like to us is that some individuals will have cracks that they don't
publish and which Hollywood is unable to revoke. Other people will have
cracks that they do publish, and which will work for all old disks." He
says it is just a matter of time until title keys are available, but
Gartner analyst Mike McGuire says Hollywood will not suffer too much as
long as they keep movies from being illegally cracked and traded while they
are still in theatres.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
DOE Awards 95 Million Hours of Supercomputing Time
HPC Wire (01/08/07)
The U.S. Energy Department's Office of Science has allocated a total of 95
million hours of computing time on some of the most powerful supercomputers
in the world to 45 projects under the aegis of its 2007 Innovative and
Novel Computational Impact on Theory and Experiment (INCITE) program. The
projects were selected on the strength of how suitable they were for
supercomputing and their research's potential impact. Nine of the winning
programs are industrial in nature, adding up to twice as many companies
with INCITE awards in 2007 versus 2006. Accelerator physics, fusion
energy, environmental science, chemical sciences, climate research,
computer science, engineering physics, life sciences, materials science,
nuclear physics, and nuclear engineering are among the research domains to
be covered in 2007. The study of global climate change, the design of less
noisy automobiles and better commercial aircraft, and analysis of
supernovas and nanomaterials are some of the research's practical
applications. "The Department of Energy's Office of Science has one of the
top 10 most powerful supercomputers in the world and four of the top 100
and we're proud to provide these resources to help researchers advance
scientific knowledge and understanding," declared Energy Secretary Samuel
Bodman. "I look forward to witnessing the promise of these efforts as some
of the world's greatest thinking minds use some of the world's greatest
thinking computers."
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Desktop Fabricator May Kick-Start Home Revolution
New Scientist (01/09/07) Simonite, Tom
Desktop fabrication could become as popular as personal computing as the
rapid prototyping machines become more affordable, according to some
advocates of the self-assembly technology. The Freeform fabricator, which
can be put together with a normal soldering iron and screwdrivers for about
$2,400, has been developed by Cornell University researcher Hod Lipson and
graduate student Evan Malone. Such rapid prototyping equipment usually
costs anywhere from $20,000 to $1.5 million. The standard Fab@Home device
connects to a desktop computer, and special software is used to control its
operation, which involves squeezing material from a mechanical syringe to
create objects layer-by-layer. The machine is about the size of a
microwave oven. Adrian Bowyer, a researcher at Bath University in the
United Kingdom, believes the unit can be used to make inexpensive
injection-molded products that are already commercially available. "I can
imagine people swapping plans of things to make online, or paying to
download them instead of going to the shop," he says. Bowyer believes
affordable rapid prototyping machines have the potential to replace
traditional manufacturing practices.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Skills Crisis Deepens as Employers Stand By
IT Week (01/08/07) Murray, James
E-Skills UK CEO Karen Price says the new quarterly skills report from her
organization "confirms that skills gaps among ICT professionals and IT
users remain a serious issue for employers." Recruitment and Employment
Confederation's Dave Pye agreed, noting that "fewer people are coming out
of university with IT skills and that is having a knock-on effect on the
market." The latest bulletin from the government and employer-backed
organization shows that during the second half of 2006 nearly one-fifth of
employers said their overall staff does not have enough IT skills, which is
a record for over a year. As for IT workers, 11 percent of employers said
their IT skill level was lacking, and most of these respondents were
medium- to large-scale companies. E-Skills surveyed 1,000 employers, and
13 percent said they were having problems finding workers for their IT
openings, especially for software engineering positions. Meanwhile,
e-Skills found that only 29 percent of IT workers had received job-related
training, which was down eight percentage points from 2001. The percentage
of employers looking to recruit IT workers rose to 17 percent.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Google Joins Large Synoptic Survey Telescope
University of Arizona (01/05/07)
Google has joined a group of 19 universities, national labs, and private
foundations that are building the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST),
to help them organize the massive amount of data the telescope will gather.
The telescope is planned to be up and running in 2013, when it will
monitor the entire visible sky each week using its three-billion pixel
digital camera. Every night will generate over 30,000 gigabits of image
data. The group aims to organize the LSST's huge amounts of information,
manage large parallel data systems, and process and analyze data
constantly, so results are available to amateur or professional researchers
in real time. Google's William Coughran says, "Google's mission is to take
the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful. The
data from LSST will be an important part of the world's information, and by
being involved in the project we hope to make it easier for that data to
become accessible and useful." The collaboration is expected the provide
the public with a novel and dynamic look at the night sky. University of
California, Davis LSST Director J. Anthony Tyson says, "Partnering with
Google will significantly enhance our ability to convert LSST data to
knowledge."
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Digital Home Still Terra Incognita
EE Times (01/08/07) Merritt, Rick
Implementing a home network is an impossibility without ingredients such
as seamless product interoperability, ease of use, and quality-of-service
(QoS). "There's a huge set of things engineers have to put in
place--digital rights management, media formats--and you have to have all
the pieces implemented before the content flows," says Intel's Brendan
Traw. "If any piece of the puzzle is not present, it doesn't work." The
state of home networking is considered to be poor because it lacks
interoperability, and there is an overabundance of QoS products as well as
home networks. Worse still, there are competing approaches to home
automation--ZigBee, Zensys' Z-Wave wireless protocol, and the Insteon
hybrid power lines/wireless networking solution from Smarthome--while
short-range personal-area networks suffer from fragmentation. A standard
protocol for preventing the copying and free distribution of premium
content on home networks does not yet exist, and different proprietary
digital rights management security products are proliferating.
Interconnect options are so numerous as to raise doubts among analysts that
any one technology will win out, while the absence of a standard operating
system is another factor, despite a continued focus on an open-source Linux
solution. At least three major groups are struggling to establish
interoperability in the digital household, and these efforts overlap at
certain points and miss important elements at others. There are too many
participants in the rapidly expanding home networking domain, and each
player's desire for an optimal system that benefits them specifically has
left the field fragmented, and will probably continue to do so.
Click Here to View Full Article
to the top
Improving Performance Support Systems Through Information
Retrieval Evaluation
Journal of Interactive Learning Research (Quarter 4, 2006) Vol. 17, No. 4,
P. 407; Schatz, Steven
Steven Schatz of the University of Hartford presents a study that analyzes
existing and new techniques for assessing the success of information
retrieval systems, arguing that the principle underlying current methods
lacks the robustness necessary to permit testing retrieval using diverse
meta-tagging schemas. Traditional measures depend on judgments of whether
a document has relevance to a specific query, and a good system returns all
relevant documents and no extraneous documents. Traditional theory does
not address questions such as when, to whom, and to what purpose are the
documents relevant. Schatz notes that metatag-based search systems such as
Dublin Core, IMS, SCORM, GEM, and others have been developed based on their
expected superiority over traditional methods, but little research has been
done to confirm their worth. Schatz's study employs the new,
non-relevance-based measures of Spink's Information Need and Cooper's
Utility to rate a self-built tag-based search tool and the open-source
Swish text-based search engine, and compares the two measures against each
other as well as against traditional measures. The two search engines were
utilized by 34 educators, who evaluated the information each search engine
retrieved. Two-way analysis of variance was used to compare construct
measures, which are the product of each of the three measures (traditional,
information need, and utility) and a satisfaction rating. A substantial
correlation between the three measures was uncovered, signaling that the
new measures offer an equivalent technique of assessing systems and have
some notable benefits, including the elimination of relevance judgments and
the capability of in-situ use of measures. "Rather than being limited to
any of these measures as a single measure, using some in conjunction with
others clearly offers a richer view," Schatz notes.
Click Here to View Full Article
- Web Link to Publication Homepage
to the top